≡ Menu

Customer Reviews

Customer Reviews

New York Life Review [Custom Whole Life Insurance]

Custom Designed Whole Life Insurance

When it comes to whole life insurance one of the premier names in the industry is New York Life.

New York Life makes our list for the top dividend paying whole life insurance companies.

NY Life has dominated the advanced markets arena for years and boasts some of the top producers in the industry, year in and year out.

In the following New York Life review we will focus on the company’s history, strong ratings, various life insurance policies, and the unique features offered.

Review of New York Life Whole Life Insurance

When seeking out the best life insurance it is imperative that you familiarize yourself with the different carriers in the marketplace before you make a decision for any one company.

The good news is that we have compiled life insurance reviews of the highest rated companies in the U.S.

About New York Life

New York Life was founded in 1845, making the company over 172 years old.

New York Life is a mutual company. In fact, New York Life is the largest fortune 500 mutual insurance company.

What is a mutual insurance company?

Mutual insurance companies are not owned by shareholders but rather by the participating policyholders, who share in the ownership rights of the company, as well as take part in the company’s profits through dividends.* Mutual companies are privately held and operate for the sole benefit of policyholders, rather than for the benefit of stockholders.

New York Life was the first company to pay a cash dividend to policyholders.

For 2016, New York Life’s dividend interest rate was 6.2% and the company will pay participating policy holders a total of $1.77 billion in dividends in 2017, a 5% increase from 2016.

*dividends are paid to participating policy owners.

New York Life Ratings

New York Life is one of the most financially secure companies available, as is reflected in it perfect 100 out of 100 Comdex ranking. New York Life receives these high marks due to its commitment to limiting risk, its competitive advantage in the marketplace, and its large capital reserves of over $538 billion of assets under management as of the end of 2016.

NY Life’s ratings as of August 2018:

  • A.M. Best rating: A++ (1 of 15)
  • Fitch rating: AAA (1 of 21)
  • Moody’s Investor Service rating: Aaa (1 of 21)
  • Standard and Poor’s rating: AA+ (2 of 20)
  • Comdex Ranking 100

Additionally, although not accredited with the BBB, New York Life Insurance Company has an A+ rating with the BBB (1), which demonstrates the Company’s commitment to serving its customers.

New York Life Products

New York Life is focused on long term care insurance, mutual funds, annuities and life insurance.

LTC Select Premier

  • Reimbursement long term care policy

Mutual Funds

  • Domestic and International Equity Funds
  • Bonds and Dividend Paying Equities
  • Non Traditional

Annuity Products

  • Guaranteed Income Annuities
  • Fixed Annuities
  • Variable Annuities

Life Insurance

  • Term Life Insurance
  • Whole Life Insurance

New York Life’s Life Insurance Policies

Although New York Life is known more for its stellar whole life insurance, the company offers both term life and whole life.

Although there are benefits to both types of coverage, in our opinion there is a clear winner in the battle between whole life vs term life.

Benefits of Term Life Insurance

  • Lower Initial Cost
  • Income Protection
  • Mortgage Protection
  • Conversion Option

Benefits of Whole Life Insurance

Although not exhaustive, below are some areas where whole life insurance can be extremely beneficial when combined with a diversified asset portfolio:

New York Life Insurance Policies

In our opinion, cash value life insurance is the way to go. New York Life whole life insurance is one of the best out there.

However, if you are considering term life insurance then pick a term policy that can be converted into a top of the line whole life insurance policy.

Alternatively, you can always get a smaller whole life policy and add a term life rider to maximize your death benefit, but also begin growing your cash value.

New York Life Term Life Insurance

Term life insurance allows you to have a large guaranteed death benefit for a lower initial cost than whole life insurance.

New York Life Insurance Company offers 10, 15 and 20 year term lengths.

New York Life’s term life insurance is convertible which allows the insured to convert all or a portion of the policy to permanent coverage prior to the end of the term or age 70. The advantage is that you can get a lot of coverage for a low cost while your income is lower, and then convert that coverage to a superior policy down the road once you become more established.

Custom Whole Life Insurance

New York Life’s Custom Whole Life Insurance provides many flexible options, including ordinary coverage to age 100 as well as limited pay whole life. Custom designed whole life insurance from New York Life lasts your entire life and offers specific guarantees, including:

  • Guaranteed death benefit,
  • Guaranteed cash accumulation and
  • Guaranteed level premiums.

Additional cash value growth is available through dividends. Although not guaranteed, New York Life has paid dividends to participating policyholders for over 100 years.

Dividends are valuable and can be used to:a

  • Purchase paid up additions
  • Pay Premiums
  • Earn interest with the company
  • Cash Out
Additional Benefits of Custom Whole Life Insurance
Tax free life insurance policy loans

You can take out tax free life insurance loans by using your cash value as collateral. New York Life’s interest rate on policy loans is variable based on Moody’s Corporate Bond Yield Average.

New York Life practices non-direct recognition. When you take out a loan, New York Life credits your interest and dividends to your total cash value, as if you did not have an outstanding loan.

That way your money in your policy continues to grow, while at the same time you can grow your money you borrowed through other cash flowing assets. This is what makes participating whole life insurance such a great asset.

Tax deferred cash value growth

Under IRC 7702, cash value life insurance grows tax deferred. And if you utilize the policy correctly you will never need to pay taxes on the cash value growth.

Additional tax deferred cash value accumulation can be acquired through the use of paid up additions. Paid up additions allow you to contribute more premium into the policy, up to, but not exceeding the modified endowment contract limit.

Tax free death benefit

You beneficiary receives the death benefit income tax free. The only way a death benefit is taxed is if your estate exceeds the federal estate tax exemption limit. If you have a large estate, careful asset protection planning is necessary.

Custom Whole Life Insurance Policy Riders

The following riders may be available as add-ons to your Term Life and Custom Whole Life Insurance Policy from New York Life.

Conversion Option – convert all or a portion of your policy to whole life insurance.

Accidental Death – additional death benefit payout if death is due to an accident.

Children’s Insurance – term rider for your kids.

Chronic Care – access a portion of your death benefit if you become permanently chronically ill.

Living Benefits – allows access to a portion of your death benefit if you are diagnosed terminally ill with a life expectancy of 12 months or less.

Spouse Paid Up Insurance Option – if your spouse is your beneficiary, this rider allows your spouse to purchase a paid up life insurance policy with no evidence of insurability, i.e. no exam or health questions.

Custom Whole Life Insurance Policy Riders

The following riders are exclusive to the Custom Whole Life Insurance Policy.

Option to Purchase Paid Up Additions – option to buy paid up additional life insurance to increase the policy’s death benefit and cash value.

Dividend Option Term – Combines decreasing term option with paid up additions dividend option.

Disability Waiver of Premium – premium is waived if you become totally disabled for 6 months or more.

Policy Purchase Option – guarantees the addition of more coverage at certain ages and life events with no evidence of insurability. This rider is a must have if you are considering life insurance for your kids.

New York Life Long Term Care Insurance

Thanks to advancements in medicine, people are living longer than ever. In the U.S., an average 65 year old man today can expect to live to age 83, and an average 65 year old woman can expect to live to age 85. And these numbers are improving every year.

Consequently, with an increase in life expectancy comes an increase in the need for long term care and the money to pay for it. Enter long term care insurance.

Some companies attach long term care onto life insurance as a rider. However, New York Life offers stand alone long term care insurance. The LTC product offered by New York Life is called NYL Secure Care. NYL Secure Care is endorsed by AARP. AARP and New  York Life have a long standing business relationship, partly due to AARP’s over 37 million member base.

NYL Secure Care

NYL Secure Care provides long term care insurance to help you pay for the rising costs of long term care. Currently, in home care and assisted living facilities cost roughly $50,000 a year. And staying in skilled nursing facilities can run as high as $100,000 a year. Long term care insurance can greatly help you pay for the high costs associated with long term care, providing wealth preservation and protection of your legacy.

One unique benefit of NYL Secure Care is that policyholders participate in dividends. After the policy has been in force for 11 years, you can receive dividends that will help lower your long term care insurance cost.

The LTC insurance policy from New York Life provides income benefit periods of 2 years up 7 years. You can choose from three elimination period options of 90, 180 or 365 days.

A waiver of premium is available which allows your policy premiums to be waived upon approval of your LTC benefit claim.

An inflation protection rider is available. The inflation protection rider helps your policy keep up with inflation by increasing your LTC benefits each year. You can choose from 5% or 3% compound interest growth, 3% simple interest growth, and CPI Auto, which tracks the consumer price index.

Interested in seeing how New York Life compares with other companies offering long term care insurance? Please give us a call today to speak to an experienced long term care life insurance agent.  

New York Life Review Conclusion

New York Life is an excellent choice for cash value whole life insurance. However, the real question is whether or not New York Life is the right company for you based on your specific needs, goals, and objectives.

Have questions or would you like to see an illustration of New York Life or any of the other top cash value life insurance companies we represent? Give us a call today for a complimentary strategy session.

13 comments… add one
  • William K September 24, 2017, 3:02 pm

    How do I get a quote for whole life insurance from New York Life?

    • Insurance&Estates September 25, 2017, 1:26 pm


      We would be happy to provide quotes on the different companies we represent.

      However, due to the unique nature of whole life insurance we will need to speak with you.

      We have sent you an email. Feel free to reply with your contact info.


    • Peter M November 14, 2017, 10:57 am

      Feel free to email me if you have any questions regarding New York Life.

  • Pam February 4, 2018, 4:30 pm

    Hello, I would like a quote for a whole life insurance, death benefit 300k. I am 29 years old. I have a son and I am healthy. Please provide a quote based on this variables. Thank you

  • Amos Davis Jr. March 6, 2018, 7:53 pm

    Need to speak with someone about participating whole life insurance for a healthy male 53 years old, non-smoker, and wife 49 years old, non-smoker, and in good health. Our 20 year level term insurance will expire in December 2019. The premiums will be very expensive. Husband currently has a $250,000 term policy, and wife has a $100,000 term policy. I am currently an AARP MEMBER.

    Amos Davis, Jr.

    • Insurance&Estates March 7, 2018, 6:30 am

      Mr. Davis,

      Thank you for visiting our website. We would be glad to help your family with Whole Life Insurance options. However, it is in your best interest that we learn more about your goals before we recommend a plan. Please be on the lookout for our email that we sent over to you.



  • Khalil May 7, 2018, 11:57 am

    Hello, would also like to explore options to determine what the best plan would be for me? could you also email me to discuss further?

    • Insurance&Estates May 7, 2018, 2:30 pm


      Thank you for stopping by. Please be on the lookout for our email.


  • Marie A. S. December 27, 2018, 11:13 am

    I do have a disability policy with your company for over 25 years. I am now considering a participating whole life with paid up rider. Please let me know if I am too old to start at 62 as I am looking for the kind of Mutual whole life insurance like infinite banking.
    Marie Sales

  • Jane Qiu February 6, 2019, 7:10 pm

    Hi NYL,

    I have a whole life with NYL for more than 20 years and I want to loan $20K for buying house! What is the loan interest rate for this $20K?


    • jose xavier soares April 21, 2019, 10:39 am

      Jane, I just saw your comments today, please give me a call so I can give you more details and rates, thanks Jose Soares ( New York Life )

  • jose soares neto April 21, 2019, 10:25 am

    Very nice information about Whole LIfe and New York LIfe.

  • jose xavier soares April 21, 2019, 10:32 am

    Very nice information about Whole Life and New York Life. Pride of working in a company like New York LIfe.

Leave a Comment